The 3 Bookshelves of Knowledge: Understanding Your Martial Arts Practice
I was looking at my bookshelves, looking for something to read. I’ve got a wide variety of genres, but heavy on martial arts, history, philosophy, and sci-fi and fantasy. And over the years I’ve gotten rid of entire boxes of books, some of which I held on to for years with the idea that I would reread them again, or hold on to them for my kids. But the reality is that most of those books were never going to be reread, and kids don’t generally want to read the books that their parents read.
Even so, I’m left with a steady accumulation of both old favorites and “read someday” books. Searching through these stacks of books made me realize how much this process mirrored my martial arts practice, where some knowledge is well trodden and familiar, whereas others are still waiting to be discovered. And some are so deeply absorbed that I practically know them by heart, even if I haven’t read them in years.
So let’s compare my bookshelves to my martial arts practice.
The Current Bookshelf
My Current Bookshelf holds the knowledge that I consciously study and draw on. When I teach, I use materials on this shelf. When I explain what I’m doing or what’s happening, this is the shelf I use. If I’m analyzing a video or watching someone else’s technique, I use this shelf. The Current Bookshelf is what I search for guidance when I’m working on new ideas or skills.
There are some items that will probably always be here. Basics of striking or blocking. Basic evasive footwork, especially angles. Posture and timing, things that are always in the forefront of my thoughts because I so frequently reference these ideas when I teach or train.
And sometimes I review items that I sorta, kinda know but need a refresher. Like reviewing basic kata from one of the ryuha, where sometimes there’s a detail of a particular strike or specific footwork that I can’t quite recall. All of this knowledge is easily accessible. I know where it is and how to find it.
The Lost Bookshelf
This bookshelf is an odd one, because it holds all the old materials that I’ve forgotten about.
Some of the material on this shelf is so deeply ingrained that I’m no longer even aware that it exists, so I forget to share it with others. I’ve discovered odd little quirks of hand movements, footwork, and positioning that I do completely subconsciously, and only discover because my students are doing exactly what I’m instructing but it’s still not working. These are skills that I’ve practiced over the years and then forgotten that I practiced them. Only careful examination of my own process reveals these hidden techniques — hidden even from me, it turns out.
Also on this shelf are the old exercises, analogies, and other teachings that I picked up along the way and are now forgotten. For example, a couple of years ago, I was at a seminar where one instructor taught a kihon happo warmup that I thought was fantastic, where the tori would flow from one kihon technique to another. I praised her for it afterward, and she laughed at me — apparently she had learned it from me years ago. As soon as she said that, I suddenly remembered teaching that exercise. So now that old material from my Lost Bookshelf has moved back to my Current Bookshelf.
This shelf also contains all the erroneous materials that I learned and discarded. It’s normal in the course of training that we try to replicate and understand things that we’ve encountered. Many of these are skills and ideas that we decided not to spend more time on.
Sometimes we abandon things because the material was simply wrong. Maybe the teacher was wrong, or our understanding was flawed, but in either case we discovered that continuing to practice this thing would actually impede our practice. So we set it aside and forgot about it.
Just as crucially, this shelf also holds the materials of ambitions that I either outgrew or forgot about. I once knew by heart most of the henka of the Gyokko ryu Joryaku no maki kata. I can’t recall them at all anymore. But I only have to see them once or twice again, and then I remember them. Once reminded, the materials on this shelf can be fairly easily retrieved. Other things aren’t so easily retrieved. Tumbling skills from my teen years are probably gone forever — I remember that I did them, but my body has zero chance of pulling them off anymore.
The Unknown Bookshelf
This is the bookshelf that holds all the materials that I never even knew existed. Here are the ideas and skills that I have no understanding of, things I’ve heard of but have no interest in, and all the things I’ve never heard of. This is a vast bookshelf. I occasionally pick up random bits of knowledge from here. A video showing me how to spin the bo staff in a way I’ve never seen. A tricky bit of escaping from the guard when groundfighting. It’s unpredictable what might grab my attention.
Sometimes the bit of knowledge is so specific that it’s almost guaranteed to be quickly forgotten. But sometimes that bit of specific bit of knowledge fills a gap that I didn’t know I was looking for. A different way of thinking about balance. A different way to move into a flanking position. A different way to talk someone down from an aggressive stance.
But a common trait is that no one can predict what knowledge will appear from this shelf. It’s not even clear that knowledge from this shelf is something that I’ll find interesting or useful at all, but now I have it.
The problem with this bookshelf is that it encompasses everything that we’re ignorant of. Some of the knowledge we know we’re ignorant about. I know that I don’t know anything about practicing kyudo (archery) or ikebana (flower arranging). But there are also areas that are so far outside my knowledge that I don’t even know they exist. The saying, “You don’t know what you don’t know” definitely applies here. It’s impossible for me to know what’s actually on the Unknown Bookshelf.
Knowledge and Training
It’s helpful to understand that our knowledge exists in these 3 areas and are fairly compartmentalized from each other. The longer that we train, the more materials end up moving from one shelf to another. And things can quickly shift from shelf to another and back again.
It’s inevitable that knowledge will shift from our Current Bookshelf to the Lost Bookshelf as we discard things we can’t use or don’t have time for. Sometimes training exercises that we used to rely on become stale, so we take a break from them and then forget them. Sometimes we’re shown a way of doing a technique that is solves so many problems that we stop doing that technique our old way, so it eventually ends up on that Lost Bookshelf.
On the other hand, some things never leave our Current Bookshelf — the true classics never go out of style, right? The more we teach, the more likely it is that we’ll consciously hold on to useful knowledge and keep it on our Current Bookshelf. As we work through our own problems in training, we draw heavily on other items on this shelf, which keeps it from migrating to the Lost Bookshelf. And hopefully there’s a continuing influx of materials from the Unknown Bookshelf to the Current Bookshelf, so that we can constantly refresh our knowledge. Sometimes this new knowledge has been deliberately searched for, and sometimes it’s the odd bit that leads us down interesting paths that we wouldn’t have normally explored. In this way, we keep our training fresh and interesting.
Consider the classic concept of shu-ha-ri.
Shu is learning a technique without deviation, ha is learning the technique’s variations and exploring its principles, and ri is the transcendence of the technique, where you’ve moved beyond it.
When you’re in the shu part of learning, the ha and ri parts of learning exist on the Unknown Bookshelf. As your training develops and you’re working on the ha stage of learning, the ri part of knowledge is still beyond you. It still sits on the Unknown Bookshelf.
But when you finally understand the ri stage of learning, there’s every possibility that much of what you studied in the shu stage is now sitting on the Lost Bookshelf. You don’t need it and haven’t needed it for a long time. But it could be that a student reminds you of an exercise that you did many years ago, which would move that exercise from the Lost Bookshelf to the Current Bookshelf (if you were so inclined to remember it, that is).
If you’ve trained for long enough, your Lost Bookshelf is bigger than a newer student’s Current Bookshelf. I often find myself forgetting to tell my students things that I consider so basic that it doesn’t occur to me that they wouldn’t know this stuff. This is why it’s so helpful to go to teachers who are only a little bit ahead of you, because the problems you’re working on are still on their Current Bookshelf. A dedicated student is always working on deepening their understanding of what’s on their Current Bookshelf, and teaching is a way of doing this.
And if you’re a hungry enough practitioner, you’re constantly looking for interesting materials from the Unknown Bookshelf. You’ll find problems that simply can’t be solved with the knowledge that sits on your Current Bookshelf, so you have to actively search your Unknown Bookshelf for possible leads to a solution. There’s magic and wonder on the Unknown Bookshelf, which you will only recognize from having enough materials on your Current and Lost Bookshelves.
More to explore
A Real Ninja Manuscript!
It sounds like a movie, but an actual ninja manuscript from the 1700s was found.
Make these wrist drills part of your routine
Keep your wrists healthy with these simple stretches.
Everyday Training
One of the challenges in training is to find the opportunities for training in everyday life.
